● Edition II Edition II · Zürich · May 2027 Edition II · May 2027 See the programme →
Take part Edition II Edition I The Record About
Partner
Partnership Contact
Edition II
Request consideration →
The Decision Room
Edition II
hello@thedecisionroom.net

Paris could plant a tree in a schoolyard, take up some asphalt and give children somewhere cooler to play. Making that same courtyard a refuge for neighbours on a hot weekend required a further decision. Someone had to open it, supervise it and leave it clean enough for school on Monday. The European climate-adaptation case account identifies guards and cleaning as costs of public access. The capital works bought the city a possibility. A continuing budget turns it into a service. City of Paris on its OASIS schoolyards, in French · Climate-ADAPT’s account of how the pilot operated

The question applies to private buildings too. To finance a retrofit, identify who pays for installation, who receives each benefit, who pays to keep the measure working and what income or budget can cover repayment. A lower energy bill, fewer hours of overheating and income available to a lender each belong on a separate line of the decision paper.

The six-year payback that goes to the tenants

Imagine a leased building in which the tenants pay for heating and the owner pays for major works. New controls would cost the owner CHF 30,000. At the assumed tariff and level of use, the engineer forecasts that tenants together would save CHF 5,000 a year. Divide one number by the other and the building has a six-year simple payback. The tenants pay the heating bills, so the CHF 5,000 a year goes to them. The owner pays for the works and receives none of it.

The example is hypothetical and excludes financing, maintenance, discounting and changes in prices or use. At that simple level, it exposes the missing decision. One option is to justify the expenditure from existing rental income. Another is a grant for eligible costs. A third is a permissible contribution, agreed between tenants and owner, that leaves occupiers better off. The property team needs to check the lease, applicable law, affordability, consent and the total effect on a tenant’s bill before treating such a payment as income.

Now offer the same building a second improvement, external shading for rooms that overheat. Count the people who occupy the exposed rooms and the hours they are likely to spend above the relevant temperature threshold under the chosen weather scenario. Check what happens during an unusually hot spell. Keeping that room usable may justify the cost on its own.

What belongs in the owner’s decision paper? Heating controls External shading
Outcome to measure Weather- and use-adjusted heating consumption against a metered baseline Occupied hours at risk of overheating before and after the proposed change
Person receiving the benefit Tenants who pay the bills under this lease Occupiers using the affected rooms and the owner where use of the building is preserved
Money available for the works Named owner budget, confirmed grant or agreed permissible contribution Named capital or operating budget, or finance with an identifiable repayment source
Continuing obligation Maintain the controls and establish who can alter their settings Inspect and maintain the shading, including the conditions in which it can be used

A cooler courtyard is also an operating commitment

Paris chose school grounds in part because they are distributed across the city. Ground that had been sealed against rain could be planted or made permeable. Some transformed yards could open to vulnerable residents outside school hours. By its update of the 2nd of November 2026, the city reported 203 OASIS courtyards and five nurseries had been adapted since 2017. The original European pilot covered ten schoolyards. Those counts describe different phases of the work. City programme and progress

The city describes measuring local thermal conditions and gathering feedback from people who use the yards. The European programme account describes the less visible arrangements for public opening. Together they give a building owner a model for an adaptation case. Define the service in enough detail to tell when it is working. A designated cool room locked outside office hours is one service. A room that a named operator opens throughout a heat alert is another. Each has its own cost and people it can reach. Each definition explains the spending on its own. Count an insurance saving only once an insurer confirms it.

What is an avoided loss worth?

For flood protection, describe the plausible event, which floors and services would be affected, the damage expected with and without the works and the risk that would remain. Keep an owner’s repair costs separate from a tenant’s business interruption. Both can matter to the decision. For the repayment forecast, count cash that reaches the borrower or a cost it could reasonably expect to stop paying. Keep the estimated value of a flood that might never happen on its own line. If an insurance saving is part of the case, obtain the insurer’s confirmed terms.

Where putting a reliable price on a benefit would be guesswork, use an objective the asset manager can test. For example, compare the cost of keeping a specified room usable during stated heat conditions across two technically feasible options. Climate-ADAPT describes cost-effectiveness and multi-criteria appraisal alongside monetised cost-benefit analysis. The choice of measure follows the decision the owner has to make. Climate-ADAPT on assessing options

Where can a Zürich owner look for support?

The Canton of Zürich’s 2026 energy funding guidance sets out measure-specific support, including insulation of roofs, walls and floors, specified heating replacements and advice. Before placing an order, check the application sequence and conditions for the works and year in question. Shading, flood protection and ongoing operation each need their own funding decision. Canton of Zürich funding and advice, in German

For larger eligible European programmes, the EIB’s ELENA facility can support preparation such as studies, audits or procurement. Its FAQ requires the applicant to be legally established in an EU Member State. A Zürich owner starts with the cantonal route above. For a qualifying European portfolio, someone also has to finance the construction and operation that follow. ELENA facility · Eligibility FAQ

For The Decision Room’s developing question on building upgrades, a case would bring the choice facing an owner. Name the two competing uses of the next capital budget, the occupiers each serves, the evidence facilities staff can verify and the obligation someone would inherit after installation. Where a duty to keep the building safe applies, name it. That is the decision a room could help examine in Zürich in May 2027. See the developing programme · Offer a case or contribution