In December 2024, the registry Isometric issued 235.53 carbon removal credits for an enhanced weathering project in Brazil. The number has two decimal places. Arriving at it required sampling soil and the water between soil particles, then comparing treatment and control plots. The project, InPlanet’s Serra da Mantiqueira, had spread crushed rock on agricultural land. The amount spread was an input to the work. The registry needed evidence of the carbon dioxide removed. Registry entry, the 23rd of December 2024 · Isometric’s account of the issuance and measurements
Anyone financing a carbon removal offtake has to fund the time between doing the work and proving the result. The buyer wants an eligible, verified unit. The supplier pays people and operating costs while evidence is collected and checked. In a pay-on-delivery deal, a signed order can establish demand while leaving the supplier responsible for financing the interval. Other agreements can move some cash forward. Their refund, delivery and replacement terms determine which risks move with it.
When the method changes
In January 2025, Isometric announced a revision to its enhanced weathering protocol informed by the early verification work. It allowed the number and depth of soil samples to reflect site conditions. Direct measurement remained part of the method. For the next project, a change intended to make a protocol more flexible poses practical questions. The parties need to know which version governs an existing field plan, who decides whether evidence already collected is sufficient and who pays to revisit the site. Isometric’s explanation of the protocol revision
A separate, public contract illustrates how parties might answer. In Frontier’s annotated offtake template, a change to a protocol starts a process involving the supplier, the buyer’s representative and the issuer. The template protects units already delivered and certain work completed or submitted before the change. It assigns the cost of complying with the protocol and implementing agreed changes to the supplier. A technical discussion about what makes a tonne eligible therefore belongs in the cash forecast too. This is Frontier’s model agreement. The payment terms of the Brazilian purchase above are undisclosed. Frontier’s published template, protocol amendments
What one quarter’s delay does to cash
Take a hypothetical supplier with €120,000 unrestricted cash on the 1st of April. Its operating bills are €60,000 a month, paid at month-end. It expects a €200,000 receipt for an accepted delivery in June. Verification moves to September. There are no other receipts or committed facilities in this example.
| At month-end | Cash after operating bills if the June receipt arrives | Cash after operating bills if verification slips |
|---|---|---|
| April | €60,000 | €60,000 |
| May | €0 | €0 |
| June | €140,000 | €60,000 short |
The June number is the first shortfall. Keeping the same monthly costs would require a further €120,000 during July and August. The cumulative gap at the end of August would be €180,000. That changes the size of any bridge. September’s position would depend on the payment date, eligibility of the eventual delivery and further costs.
A buyer agreeing to a later date might preserve the commercial relationship. The supplier still needs cash for its June invoices. A buyer advance, working-capital loan or equity contribution could address the timing, depending on the agreement. If the buyer advances €60,000 against the same €200,000 delivery, show €60,000 cash now and €140,000 still due on acceptance. Counting the original invoice in full as well would overstate the cash coming in by €60,000.
Three different things a supplier can mean by “late”
| What happened? | Decision required |
|---|---|
| Removal may have occurred, but the evidence is awaiting verification | Establish what evidence is outstanding, who can complete it, when the registry and buyer can act, and how the supplier operates until then. |
| The project produced fewer eligible tonnes than it contracted to deliver | Read the quantity, notice, remedy and default provisions. Ask whether later production can be committed and whose written approval would change the schedule. |
| The applicable measurement method or project design needs to change | Establish who can approve the revision, which work is covered by it, who bears the cost and whether any units already delivered are affected. |
Frontier describes its own offtakes as multi-year purchases paid on delivery, subject to project-specific conditions. Its template calls for an explanation when annual delivery falls short. A supplier may propose revised quantities in future years, subject to the buyer’s approval. A remedy therefore needs the seller’s revised figures and the buyer’s approval. A prospective lender needs to know which obligations are binding and who can change them. Frontier purchasing approach · Delivery and shortfall provisions
Follow one unit past the invoice
The evidence needed to issue a credit, the event that releases payment, the registry record of retirement and the basis for a corporate claim can all sit with different people. Ask each for the document they control. Where a company is seeking a claim under VCMI’s voluntary framework, assurance of specified metrics is a further step. The signed offtake establishes what was purchased on agreed terms. Each later piece of evidence comes from the person who controls it. VCMI’s Claims Code and assurance framework
For a storage or monitoring obligation, take the exercise one year beyond the last delivery. Name who retains the records, funds monitoring and responds to a release or loss. Record what rights pass to a successor if the operator changes. A buyer may have an agreed remedy against one company while the records sit with another. Put those names beside the relevant dates before the last payment leaves the account.
The carbon removal room at The Decision Room’s first Zürich edition recorded a proposal to advocate for separate markets and demand instruments for removals and avoided emissions. It shapes how a buyer drafts a purchase brief. A buyer who needs atmospheric removal should say what physical result and evidence it will accept. For Edition II in May 2027, our proposed durable-removal discussion addresses delivery obligations that continue beyond the first purchase. Bring one non-confidential obligation whose owner, funding or lifetime is uncertain. Get the full Edition I report to read session seven · TDR’s carbon removal essay · Proposed Energy & Decarbonisation work · How places are reviewed